What Is the Best Toaster for Bagels?

Choose a toaster with extra-wide slots (at least 1.5 inches) to fit thick bagels.

A dedicated bagel setting toasts the cut side only, keeping the outside soft.
Consider the number of slots based on how many bagels you toast at once.
Look for features like frozen setting, high-lift lever, and removable crumb tray.
Read user reviews to gauge browning consistency and durability.

What to Look for in a Bagel Toaster

Bagel toasters need wide slots to fit thick bagels without forcing them. A dedicated bagel setting toasts the cut side while leaving the outer side soft. Look for a toaster with at least 1.5-inch wide slots. Even browning matters because bagels have dense dough that can burn unevenly. Models with centering guides hold the bagel upright for consistent toasting. High wattage, around 1200 to 1500 watts, speeds up toasting and helps achieve a crisp exterior.

Best Overall: Cuisinart CPT-440

The Cuisinart CPT-440 is a four-slot toaster with extra-wide 1.5-inch slots. It has a dedicated bagel setting that toasts only the cut side. The toaster features a frozen bagel function as well. Owners report even browning across all four slots. The CPT-440 has a high lift lever that makes removing small bagels easy.

Best Value: Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster

The Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster offers a bagel setting at an affordable price. It has extra-wide slots that fit thick bagels and artisan bread. The toaster includes a cancel button and a frozen setting. Owners report that the bagel function toasts the cut side nicely.

Best for Thick Bagels: Breville the Smart Toaster BTA820XL

The Breville the Smart Toaster BTA820XL is a premium toaster with extra-wide slots that accommodate thick bagels. It features a 'A Bit More' function that adds extra toasting time. The toaster has a lift-and-look mechanism to check browning without canceling. Owners praise its even toasting and durability.

Best for Small Kitchens: Dualit Classic 2-Slot Toaster

The Dualit Classic 2-Slot Toaster is a compact and stylish option for small kitchens. It has a manual lever and a unique design that allows you to control toasting time. The toaster features extra-wide slots that fit bagels. Owners appreciate its retro look and build quality.

Common questions

How wide should a toaster slot be for bagels?

Look for slots at least 1.5 inches wide. Standard bagels are about 1 inch thick, but extra-wide slots handle thicker bagels and artisan bread. Measure your bagels to ensure they fit without forcing.

What does the bagel setting on a toaster do?

The bagel setting toasts only the cut side of the bagel while keeping the outer side soft. It uses lower heat on the outer side to avoid burning. This gives you a crispy interior and a chewy exterior.

Can I toast frozen bagels in a regular toaster?

Yes, but you may need to toast them twice. A toaster with a frozen setting automatically adjusts the toasting time. If your toaster lacks that, use a lower setting and toast longer.

Is a 4-slice toaster better for bagels?

A 4-slice toaster is better if you toast multiple bagels at once. It saves time for families or gatherings. However, it takes up more counter space. Choose based on your needs.

What is the best toaster for bagels under?

The Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster is a good budget option. It has extra-wide slots and a bagel setting. It's affordable and performs well for basic bagel toasting.

How do I toast bagels without burning them?

Use the bagel setting if available. Place the bagel cut side up. Set the shade dial to a medium level. Check the bagel periodically to avoid over-toasting. Some toasters have a lift-and-look feature.

Are expensive toasters worth it for bagels?

Expensive toasters often have better build quality and more features. They may toast more evenly and last longer. If you toast bagels daily, a premium model can be worth the investment.

Can I use a toaster oven for bagels?

Yes, a toaster oven can toast bagels. It offers more control and can handle larger quantities. However, it takes longer and uses more energy. A dedicated toaster is faster for small batches.